Alan Shearer is raising concerns about Nick Woltemade, calling him “an issue for Newcastle” as the player faces scrutiny regarding his role in Eddie Howe’s system and recent performances.
The Germany international joined the Magpies from Stuttgart for £69 million in August, essentially replacing Alexander Isak after his record transfer to Liverpool.
Woltemade initially made a strong impact, netting seven goals in his first 23 Premier League matches, all of which came before the end of last year.
However, 2026 has seen a different story unfold for him, as he has struggled to find the net in seven consecutive league games and hasn’t started any of Newcastle’s last four Premier League fixtures.
After Newcastle’s defeat to Manchester City, Shearer voiced his doubts regarding Woltemade’s fit within Howe’s tactical approach.
“Clearly, Woltemade is an issue for Newcastle. The investment they made, nearly £70 million, and the choice to use Gordon as a centre-forward indicates he hasn’t met the expectations they had for that role,” Shearer stated. “They are still trying to determine what works best for him. Is he a No. 10? Probably not. They attempt to play him in more of a midfield position, yet it’s evident he struggles with pressing because he lacks the energy and stamina required to succeed in Howe’s system, which has been crucial to Newcastle’s success.”
“Witness that with the second Manchester City goal, when he attempted to press but was easily bypassed. He is indeed an issue. The Alexander Isak situation has complicated things for everyone—it has not played out well.”
Woltemade’s decline in form aligns with Yoane Wissa’s return to fitness, leading Howe to deploy Anthony Gordon as a central striker rather than relying on the 24-year-old.
This week, reports have emerged suggesting that Newcastle might be open to selling Woltemade if the right offer materializes. Bayern Munich, which had discussions before his move to England, is reportedly keeping an eye on the situation, although Newcastle does not actively seek to offload him.
The club seems focused on integrating him into a deeper, false nine or No. 10 role within Howe’s strategies, rather than viewing him solely as a direct replacement for Isak.
Howe has countered any notions of dissatisfaction, affirming that Woltemade remains a vital component of his plans.
“He appears genuinely happy. What you see is what you get with Nick. He’s always upbeat and has fostered a close bond with Malick [Thiaw], which is encouraging to observe,” Howe explained. “He is well-liked among the squad, which is significant for any player. The group appreciates his character; he contributes to the team spirit with his good humor and relatability.”
“Reports suggesting he is unhappy don’t align with the player I see. In recent matches, he has performed impressively, and I have been pleased with his level of play. I don’t perceive any issues.”
The difference in Shearer’s perspective and Howe’s public endorsement highlights the ambiguity surrounding Woltemade’s role.
Initially signed as a headline fixture in place of Isak, he has shown flashes of potential but has yet to solidify his position as Newcastle’s clear focal point.
READ NEXT: Arsenal derby hero Ebere Eze the narrative king again as sorry Spurs destroyed
